logologo_light
  • HOME
  • FOR SALE
    • ALL CURRENT LISTINGS
    • 30 Northcote Ave, Killara
    • 59 Arnold Street, Killara
    • 63 Arnold Street, Killara
    • 139A Koola Ave, East Killara
  • SOLD
  • OUR TEAM
  • NEWS
  • SOTHEBY’S
    • Sydney Sotheby’s Realty
    • The Goldman Brothers Team
  • CONTACT
  • HOME
  • FOR SALE
    • ALL CURRENT LISTINGS
    • 30 Northcote Ave, Killara
    • 59 Arnold Street, Killara
    • 63 Arnold Street, Killara
    • 139A Koola Ave, East Killara
  • SOLD
  • OUR TEAM
  • NEWS
  • SOTHEBY’S
    • Sydney Sotheby’s Realty
    • The Goldman Brothers Team
  • CONTACT

Caviar & wine? What this court ruling means for you

Indulgences such as caviar, wagyu beef and the finest bottles of wine shouldn’t count against you when lenders assess your application for finance, a Federal Court judge has said. Ok, so maybe Federal Court Justice Nye Perram has a slightly different grocery list to the rest of us. But his recent judgement should be welcome news to potential borrowers who have splashed out on the odd luxury over the past six months and are worried that it would completely derail their loan application.

This article is written by finance industry heavyweights, and our advisors for all things financial; LogiX Financial Services

—–

So what’s going on?

Well, the corporate watchdog (the Australian Securities and Investments Commission, aka ASIC) filed a court case against Westpac in 2017 in an attempt to strengthen lending standards.

ASIC argued that Westpac’s automated decision system relied solely on a household expenses benchmark that underestimated real living expenses and, as such, was flawed.

However, Justice Perram ruled that Westpac had done nothing wrong by using its automated system, rather than manually checking the borrowers’ living expenses, when approving more than 260,000 home loans between December 2011 and March 2015.

A tasty morsel from the judgement

Justice Perram said that current laws do not explicitly require banks to check expenses.

“[I’m] unable to discern why, as a matter of principle, the consumer’s declared living expenses must be considered,” he said.

“I may eat wagyu beef every day washed down with the finest shiraz but, if I really want my new home, I can make do on much more modest fare.

“The fact that the consumer spends $100 per month on caviar throws no light on whether a given loan will put the consumer into circumstances of substantial hardship.”

Basically, what Justice Perram is saying is that just because you fork out for expensive items before you apply for a mortgage, doesn’t mean you’re incapable of reducing your expenses once you’ve taken out a loan.

What happened next?

The Australian Financial Review (AFR) followed up on the decision with a scathing smackdown of ASIC in an editorial that asked: “why did ASIC even bother?”.

“Leave banks – the institutions with the expertise and incentive to write good loans – to assess risks for home loans. Not second-guessing bureaucrats,” the editorial stated.

“After all, it is hardly in a bank’s own interest to lend to people who are unlikely to be able to pay the money back.”

CoreLogic Research Analyst Cameron Kusher meanwhile wrote that it was not only a big win for Westpac, but the entire lending industry.

“The judge in the ASIC/Westpac case seems to really get it. While you might spend a lot more before you get a mortgage, getting a loan is about knowing someone has the capacity to change their spending behaviour once they have a mortgage,” he said.

“Lending has become so prescriptive when it is really the unexpected life events that cause someone to default on their mortgage. You can’t foresee everything.”

Meanwhile, ASIC commissioner Sean Hughes said the commission was consulting on new guidance in relation to responsible lending obligations.

What this means for your next loan application

Westpac says the decision provides clarity for the interpretation of responsible lending obligations, however consumer groups who found the decision “disappointing” are calling on the government to amend responsible lending laws.

While this court ruling may have the potential to somewhat relax the tight lending standards currently in place, it’s better to be safe than sorry when applying for a loan and we can provide you with some good tips on how to get your accounts in order.

After all, it is still up to the lender’s discretion (perhaps hold off on the caviar for a while longer!).

——

So if you’re considering applying for finance in the near future, get in touch with LogiX Financial Services.

They’d be more than happy to help guide you through the ever-evolving responsible lending landscape.

Disclaimer: The content of this article is general in nature and is presented for informative purposes. It is not intended to constitute financial advice, whether general or personal nor is it intended to imply any recommendation or opinion about a financial product. It does not take into consideration your personal situation and may not be relevant to circumstances. Before taking any action, consider your own particular circumstances and seek professional advice. This content is protected by copyright laws and various other intellectual property laws. It is not to be modified, reproduced or republished without prior written consent.

 

Share this:

  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window)

Related

  • Posted by LogiX Financial Services
  • On August 30, 2019
  • 0 Comment
  • 0 likes
Tags: Finance, lending, LogiX, Mortgages, property
Recent
  • When normal is sculptured to become the beautiful – Seed House
  • Federation Classic in Killara Restored to Perfection
  • Freedom to move. Stamp duty reforms gain momentum
  • Sydney Design – ‘GB House’ by Renato D’Ettorre Architects
  • The Rise & Rise of Sydney’s Prestige Property Market
Categories
  • Architecture
  • Finance
  • Latest News
  • Lifestyle
  • LogiX Financial Services
  • Market Report
  • Property Finance
  • Property Investment
  • Property Market
  • Residential Sales
  • Sydney Sotheby's North
  • Sydney Sotheby's Realty
POPULAR POSTS
  • When normal is sculptured to become the beautiful – Seed HouseDecember 7, 2020
  • Sotheby’s International Realty VideoFebruary 3, 2017
  • Ever Thought about a Bridging Loan?March 3, 2017
  • Interest Rates – which rate are you on?March 29, 2017
  • Australian Immigration UpdateJune 1, 2017

Interest Rates – which rate are you on?

Previous thumb

Lending update – do you have an interest only loan?

Next thumb
Scroll
Sotheby’s International Realty

Specialising in the sale of luxury homes on Sydney’s Upper North Shore, our dedicated Sydney North team continues to build on their reputation for integrity, confidentiality and effective negotiation.

Part of a global network, Sydney Sotheby’s International Realty ‘Brings the World to Your Door’.

CONNECT
INSTAGRAM
Another lovely vendor review from our most recent Another lovely vendor review from our most recent sale at 31 Powell Street, Killara 😍🏡
SOLD - 31 Powell Street, Killara 🏡 Another exce SOLD - 31 Powell Street, Killara 🏡 Another exceptional result for another exceptional client 😍
Another brilliant House of The Week feature secure Another brilliant House of The Week feature secured for our clients at 30 Northcote Avenue, Killara thanks to @sheppearda and the @northshoretimes 🏡
Grandeur 🏡 30 Northcote Avenue, Killara Grandeur 🏡

30 Northcote Avenue, Killara
The secret of property photography is to move ever The secret of property photography is to move every piece of furniture in the home to the most dysfunctional place possible...but it looks great 📸🏡
Presenting 31 Powell Street, Killara 🏡 Presenting 31 Powell Street, Killara 🏡
Always On 📱 Always On 📱
Presenting 30 Northcote Avenue, Killara 🏡 Presenting 30 Northcote Avenue, Killara 🏡
2020 was one of our best years yet and three new b 2020 was one of our best years yet and three new beautiful homes will hit the market next week 👊🏽 To say we’re excited to break more records in 2021 would be an understatement 🏡
Ready. Set. Sell. Ready. Set. Sell.
Follow on Instagram
CONTACT US

Ben Cohen: 0400 501 544
Mark Goldman: 0411 193 299
Barry Goldman: 0418 890 210
Spencer Tsang: 0403 128 804

Tel: 02 8355 6783
Fax: 02 9362 1930

> EMAIL US

Copyright 2020 - The Goldman Brothers - Admin Login | Site by AMC Creative